Robert Tickner • January 21, 2025
Image of Robert Tickner
Is Your Website a Failure? 3 Reasons Sites Fail (And How to Save Yours)

Is your website letting you down? Are you a Melbourne small business owner frustrated with low engagement, a lack of leads, or just a website that looks like it's stuck in the past?


I get it. I'm Rob, and I help small businesses in Melbourne like yours not just get online, but to actually stand out online. It’s my goal to take your tired or ineffective website and give it a digital turnaround. I achieve this through clean layouts, fast load times, and user-friendly navigation, combined with clear calls-to-action that turn visitors into leads.


The end result? More clicks, more calls, and more customers for your Melbourne business.


This article will take you through proven, effective methods to transform your failing website, ensuring it starts driving your business forward.



Is Your Website Showing These Website Failure Signs?


Before we jump into fixes, let's make sure we're diagnosing the right problem. It’s like a car; if the engine's sputtering, we need to check what’s going on before pulling it apart. For websites, common symptoms of a failing website include poor website performance.


This often means few visitors, and those that do click on your website leave almost immediately. This is known as a high bounce rate and it can be a major alarm bell.


Do you have people visit your website but then they don’t take any action or they aren't interacting? Things like this, along with low conversion rates – not getting enquiries or sales from your website – are a few signals. Then you might also have negative feedback, or it might be because your website doesn't even work well on smartphones, which, let's face it, most people in Melbourne use every day.


You can’t fix poor website performance if you don’t know it’s broken, so being able to identify these symptoms early is the first step to getting things right.



1. Is Poor UX Design Turning Visitors Away?


To start the website transformation, we need to know where the problems actually lie. It’s a bit like doing the ground work before renovating a house; an effective website audit is the first step before the hammer comes out. This involves a good website audit to identify the trouble spots.


First, a ‘technical’ audit checks that all the nuts and bolts are working such as your page speed, if it’s mobile-friendly using Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test Tool, and checking for broken links all very important factors that can hold your website back.


Then we look at the user experience (UX) with an audit, which is how people find and use the website. Are they finding it easy to navigate? Or is it like walking through a maze?


And then finally, is your content valuable and useful or is it stale and not helpful? Also, it pays to look at what your Melbourne competitors are doing with their websites. Knowing all this will then give you a starting point to work from and set achievable goals for improvement.

A woman is sitting on a couch holding a cell phone and a laptop doing research in ho to make their website better.

2. Is Your Lack Of Local SEO Making Your Website Invisible?


Okay, now for the exciting part: making those changes. This is where things get real for your digital turnaround. Here are the things I use to create digital transformations that are proven and tested to work.


  • Redesigning for a Better User Experience: It starts with how your website looks and how easy it is to use. Clean, intuitive navigation, a clear visual hierarchy and easy to read fonts all help users stay longer and ultimately convert from just a website user to a paying client. Think of it like walking into a well-organised shop. Everything is where it should be and feels intuitive.


  • Revitalising Website Content: Is your content providing useful and current information or does it just sit there? We’ll make sure it's speaking to your ideal client using valuable content like case studies, or helpful how to guides that your target audience will love. I ensure your website not only looks good, but that it also provides true value.


  • Local SEO Optimisation: You’ve got a great website, but no one is seeing it? That's like having the best shop in Melbourne hidden away in a back alley. Through search engine optimisation (SEO) such as using targeted local keywords, and local SEO tactics (think Google Business Profile optimisation), and other technical optimisations to make sure you’re popping up when local customers are searching for your services.


  • Conversion Rate Optimisation (CRO): Turning visitors into paying customers is key. We do this with A/B testing by optimising key areas such as call-to-actions, landing pages, contact forms and other touch points with CRO tools. That makes sure that all your hard work converting clients to your website gets converted to leads, calls, and of course - customers.


  • Integrating Google Analytics: Without tracking and measurement, you can't actually tell what's working and what's not. By having a Google analytics setup that tracks your results we know what to do to improve even further!


  • Mobile Optimisation: Most people will see your website on a mobile device, so having a fully mobile-friendly website is no longer optional – it's essential! Your website has to work great regardless of the screen it is being displayed on and using Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test Tool will be an essential part of this process.



3. The "Daily Grind" Website Failure: And How They Turned It Around


To put all of this into perspective, imagine a local Melbourne cafe called “The Daily Grind.” They had a website that wasn't mobile-friendly, it was hard to navigate, had limited information, and as a result, it was losing customers to other cafes. It was basically an old, broken website!


We started with a thorough website audit and focused on creating a brand new design, improved menus for their online ordering, implemented targeted local keywords for local searches, and made it easy for users to navigate and access information like opening times, and locations.


The result? A significant increase in online orders, table reservations, and positive customer engagement. With the website being a much more accurate reflection of what they offer their customers.



Ready to Transform Your Failing Website from a Liability to an Asset?


To summarise, if your Melbourne business's website isn't bringing in the results you need, you don’t need to settle for it. A digital turnaround is definitely possible through a strong website audit, followed by a series of targeted, actionable strategies. From a user-friendly design, effective content, local search optimisation, and mobile optimisation with the right tactics, you can turn a failing website into your best marketing tool.


Ready to transform your failing website from a liability to an asset?


Contact me today to see how we can work together. Let's get your Melbourne business standing out online and driving your business goals forward, the way it should. Call Robert in Melbourne on 0450 616 000.

Image of Robert Tickner

Hi, I’m Robert Tickner, an Australian-based web design expert with over six years of experience helping small businesses succeed online. I specialise in creating custom websites and optimising for local SEO to drive traffic, boost visibility, and support business growth.

Want More Leads and Sales?


I can help you with a modern, high-converting website that can help get you more leads and boost your sales immediately.


Ready to see results?



A close up of a cell phone displaying the google search page for business reviews.
By Robert Tickner January 31, 2025
Learn how to turn Google reviews into opportunities for your business. Boost local SEO, build trust, and attract more customers. Start today!
website audit for a small businesses
By Robert Tickner January 30, 2025
Learn how to conduct a website audit for your Melbourne business. Improve performance, boost local SEO, and attract more customers. Start today!
Two people looking at a professional web design for a small business on a desktop computer.
By Robert Tickner January 29, 2025
Hiring a web designer? Melbourne business owners must ask these key questions! Avoid mistakes and get results from your website investment with our expert advice.